Back to Balance But Not Prudence: Sault Chamber


In response to Budget 2017, the Ontario Chamber of Commerce (OCC) and the Sault Ste. Marie Chamber of Commerce (SSMCOC) today expressed concern that there is no clear path for long-term fiscal prudence, while commending the government for Ontario’s first balanced budget since the global recession. While there is no deficit over the planning period, there is also no plan for surplus. Given that, downward payment on the debt will be pushed beyond the medium-term. This will place tremendous fiscal burden on future generations and considerable pressure on future economic planning.

“Budget 2017 demonstrates that much of Ontario’s fiscal outlook will depend on the prosperity of our private sector,” says Richard Koroscil, Interim President & CEO, Ontario Chamber of Commerce. “The government acknowledged that business investment spending slowed in 2016, though expects firms to increase investment by 3.1 percent, annually, to 2020 – an amount that would outpace growth in real GDP growth and household spending. These assumptions depend upon business confidence – which has fallen precipitously in recent years according to the Ontario Economic Report – and U.S. demand, which is subject to considerable risk given recent comments by American President Donald Trump.”

Rory Ring, Executive Director for the Sault Ste. Marie Chamber of Commerce commends the government for bringing in a balanced budget but expresses concerns on the path taken to get to this point and what that holds for the future. Ring says, “We remain deeply concerned about the state of the province’s finances and its debt, which are a drag on business confidence and jeopardize the sustainability our public services. A balanced budget should be the first step toward beginning to pay down debt, instead what we saw yesterday was the balance used as a springboard to launch new spending.”

Ontario’s revenues rely on the level and pace of economic activity of the province, but Budget 2017 offers limited vision for how to ensure that private-sector economic growth will continue to rise. Promised Corporate Income Tax rate relief, which the government paused following the economic downturn, were not reinstated. In the 2009 budget, the province pledged to reduce the Corporate Income Tax (CIT) rate to 10 percent by 2013. Within ten years it was estimated that the value of this CIT reduction would see Ontario benefit by increased capital investment of $47 billion, increased annual incomes of $29.4 billion and an estimated 591,000 net new jobs. However, the CIT reduction promise was halted in 2012 in light of the province’s deteriorating fiscal situation, and so the CIT rate remained at 11.5 percent.

Ring notes that after close to two years of significant lobbying by the Ontario Chamber network on the government’s Cap and Trade program, the government is still providing little detail on how they intend to re-invest the revenues. “The program is in place, businesses and consumers are paying more into the provincial coffers as a result,” says Ring. “We expected more detail on Cap and Trade re-investment in this budget.”

“The provincial government has insisted that it will invest Cap and Trade proceeds to help business and industry remain competitive and that it will do so in a ‘transparent and accountable way’” explains Ring. “Yet, government has provided little detail on how these proceeds will be spent or what programs they will fund. This is a cause for concern and uncertainty to both businesses and communities that find themselves particularly exposed to the effects of carbon pricing, like Sault Ste. Marie.” Ring adds that the Sault Ste. Marie Chamber will partner with the Sudbury Chamber of Commerce to bring forward a resolution to the Ontario Chamber of Commerce next week to lobby the government to outline a plan to re-invest Cap and Trade dollars back into communities that are home to businesses hit hardest by Cap and Trade costs.

The Sault Ste. Marie Chamber of Commerce is concerned about the budget’s cut of $70 million dollars to the Ministry of Northern Development and Mines. MNDM oversees the Northern Ontario Heritage Fund Corporation (NOHFC), a crown corporation and development agency that invests in northern businesses and municipalities through conditional contributions, forgivable performance loans, incentive term loans and loan guarantees. The Chamber notes that both MNDM and NOHFC are integral to the economic development and well-being of Northern Ontario.

The local Chamber also expresses concerns over the 2% cap placed on increases to rental rates and the impact that this will have on rental property owners. The cap will make it increasingly difficult for property owners to stay ahead of, and recoup, rising expenses such as energy and heating which have outpaced rental increase rates in recent years.

One bright spot in Budget 2017 were details provided around the clear commitment by Ontario’s private sector to providing job growth for the province. The budget suggests that 98 percent of all new jobs since the recession in Ontario have been full time, and 78 percent in above-average wage industries. This positive economic activity by Ontario’s private sector demonstrates a clear commitment to good, quality jobs throughout our province.

The Sault Chamber is also pleased to learn that funding to the Connecting Links program will increase to $30 million per year by 2018-9, but cautions that even with the increase, the program is still not funded to the level that it should be. Connecting Links provides critical funding needed to maintain infrastructure that supports the provincial transportation system.

“Government must listen to its own budget document on the consistent creation of high-quality jobs when they consider the final report of the Changing Workplaces Review, expected in the coming weeks,” says Koroscil. “While Premier Wynne and others have recently spoken about the rise of part-time work and concern over precarious work more generally, Budget 2017 states that the majority of the jobs created since the recession were in industries that pay above-average wages, in the private sector and in full-time positions.”

– Ontario will not return to planned Corporate Income Tax cuts, jeopardizing tens of billions of dollars in potential capital investment and hundreds of thousands of news jobs.

– While there is no deficit over the planning period, there is also no plan for surplus. Ontario’s debt will rise by 21 per cent in the next three years as a result of interest charges, with no plans to begin debt repayment.

– 98% of all new jobs since the recession in Ontario have been full time, and 78% in above-average wage industries. This positive economic activity by Ontario’s private sector demonstrates a clear commitment to good jobs throughout our province and challenges many recent comments about precarious work and the need for the Changing Workplaces Review.

– Private sector investment is predicted to grow by 3.1 per cent, annually, to 2020, an amount that would outpace growth in real GDP growth and household spending.

The Sault Ste. Marie Chamber of Commerce has been the voice of the Sault’s Business Community since 1889. Visit

The Ontario Chamber of Commerce is Ontario’s Business Advocate, for more information go to


  1. Steve, before you comment, why don’t you look at my voting record. I’ve had a conservative position through out my terms, strongly advocating for reduced costs and increasing revenue sources. Steve, I think maybe you’ve got me confused with someone else. Call me anytime to discuss.

  2. If you believe Ontario premier kathleen wynne’s claim that through her sound fiscal management she has balanced the province’s books and can now spend more on public services, there’s a bridge in Brooklyn, that you might be interested in, that’s 4 sale.
    It’s the same trick wynne is using to “lower” our electricity bills starting June 1 by 17% (plus the earlier 8% HST cut on Jan. 1) by racking up ” $25 BILLION IN NEW DEBT ” to be paid back by you & me, the taxpayers. Folks, this once proud province needs to dump this current liberal government & I mean PRONTO !!! Seriously folks. Have a great weekend.

    • Frank…she has lost the support of the voting public. Why do the other two parties not demand that she quit now and call an election ?? Why do we have to suffer until 2018? The Liberals are floundering in a sinking ship and no one is coming to their rescue. She is not even capable of calling the Soo by-election even though she has a sacrificial candidate ready to go.

    • Reminds me of my property tax bill in 2014. Zero percent increase in 2014 and only 2014 which was just in time for an election. Massive tax hikes before and after that have added up to 38.4% over your time on Council so far, Frank. Man, you don’t like other people using your tricks. Many citizens see through you, though.

      • I was thinking the same thing Steve. There must be a course somewhere that Frank and other elected officials take which allows them to try and fool the public. Our city council is as bad if not worse than the Liberals.

  3. How many voters really understand what a balanced budget really means ?? I am sure many will laud the Liberals for getting rid of the debt. The two of course are NOT once and the same. I hope voters are not influenced by these crooks. What would make anyone think the Liberals are finally being honest and looking out for our good? They have been a total disaster since being elected and re-elected. Sure…goodies are coming forth by the bushel basket but they are all adding to the debt.them ?? I am disappointed that Ms. Amaroso is willing to connect with and support such a group of thugs. Does she not have a concern about them ??
    Also…keep in mind…the NDP with Ms. Horvath propped up and supported these Liberals when she had the chance to dump them. She cannot be forgiven for this. The NDP will promise the moon because they know full well they will never form another Ontario government. Don’t be fooled.

Comments are closed.