What does a Doug Ford Victory Mean For Health Care in Ontario?

34
Natalie Mehra. Executive Director, Ontario Health Coalition addresses media and crowd about ongoing pressure to public healthcare in the province.

Media Release. By Natalie Mehra – Executive Director, Ontario Health Coalition.

In the last days before the election, we tried to find a way to contrast Doug Ford’s belated “platform” with the former Conservative government of Mike Harris to see how far apart they were. Though I knew the cuts were massive, I was still shocked to discover that Ford’ planned cuts to provincial revenues — the money used to fund our public programs and services including health care — are‎ actually deeper than Mike Harris’. The Harris government cut $13 billion in its first four years. Doug Ford plans to cut $22 billion over three years. ‎

While the Ontario Health Coalition is non-partisan, and we do not endorse any political party, we try tell the truth, no matter who it is in power, and now we must face a very serious reality. With cuts on this scale, there are only a few options– significant downsizing of the workforce, an attempt to restructure through mass amalgamations, dramatic privatization, and cuts to services.

While there is no doubt that there are some administrative efficiencies to be found, there is simply no way they add up to $22 billion, an amount that would be the deepest cuts ever. ‎For example, if every Ontario hospital CEO’s pay was cut by $200,000, the total “saved” would be a few million. Ditto if 200 people were cut from the LHINs. Moreover, our experience has been that every round of cuts has spawned a whole set of consultants and managers to “find efficiencies” and manage the cuts, and there are all kinds of costs associated with moving services around and consolidating them. For eg. the Provincial Auditor calculated the cost of the hospital amalgamations and closures under Mike Harris to be $3.9 billion. That was $3.9 billion spent to save $800 million. I fear the public has been oversold on an idea of finding efficiencies that are very significantly overstated, and this has led us all down a very dangerous path.

Leading into and throughout the election campaign we tried to push all of t‎he political parties to make firm commitments to restore public hospital funding and reopen closed wards and operating rooms. After 40 years of downsizing, the conversation, about hospitals at least, needed to be about rebuilding capacity, not cuts. By the best evidence hospitals need 5.3 percent funding increase per year for four years in order to stave off cuts; and our province, which has cut beds to a level unheard of in Canada — or among our peer nations– needs urgently to reopen beds. (By that we mean funded beds as there are plenty of closed down wards and entire floors of hospitals due to inadequate funding.)

While we were definitely successful in setting the crisis of hospital overcrowding as a key issue, Doug Ford’s promise was simply to “end hallway medicine” and that there will be “no cuts” without any commitment to any level of funding. In Wallaceburg, at a donut shop appearance, local health coalition members also asked Ford not to privatize hospitals and he promised this. They taped him on their cell phones. We’ll have to hold him to that.

So the key question remains this: how will Doug Ford cut billions from provincial revenues when Ontario already funds its hospitals (and in fact all our public services) at the lowest level per person, in Canada?

In addition to the budget cuts, there is reason to be wary. The Fords’ record of trying to privatize long-term care at the City of Toronto — a plan that we successfully stopped — may be an indication of things to come. Reuben Devlin, former Conservative Party President and CEO of Humber River Regional Hospital is one of Ford’s closest health care advisors. He closed 3 hospitals at Humber River, to build one privatized P3. One of the hospitals he closed down was in one of the poorest neighbourhoods of Toronto. Those of us concerned about mega-mergers and a new wave of expensive and destructive amalgamations should take heed.

The fact that Doug Ford did not make much in the way of clear commitments could afford him wide latitude to do whatever he wants in government. But on the other hand he also has no mandate for service cuts and privatization. In fact, our strength and the issues that we had successfully made top-of-mind leading into the election, meant that he had to commit to no cuts, no lay offs, and an end to hallway medicine in order to get elected, and, importantly as noted above, no privatization. We can be proud of that. In addition, leading into the election, the Conservatives were put into a position of voting in favour of legislation to bring in minimum care standards in long-term care. We will have to hold Ford’s government to these commitments.

But we have been around long enough to know that there is a lot of work ahead. We are going to have to be ready to fight. The forces of cuts and privatization are now ascendant and it will take a great deal of strength to protect public health care and our core principles of equity and public non-profit service in the upcoming months. We will need your help, and with it, ‎we commit to doing everything possible to protect local services from cuts and privatization, to advocate for the public interest, and to uphold the principles of public health care for all in our province. ~ Protecting Public Medicare for All ~

http://www.ontariohealthcoalition.ca/

 

34 COMMENTS

  1. First Ford can cut his salary as Premier as he is not in need of it since he inherited his fortune, and that will help but if social services get cut you will see a fight, if jobs in the public sector is challenged you will see a fight thats to all that voted for Ford

  2. Given the choices that we had to vote for, I would say that I saw this coming. The liberals have blundered their way through 15 years, spending frivolously our hard earned tax dollars on trips abroad, a big yellow duck that we don’t own, paying criminals millions because a terrorist has hurt feelings. I’m sure someone else can fill in a few that I missed. So…. With an increase in debt, we need to cut it somewhere, and in walks ford, the election practically handed to him because people are either too set in their ways to vote for a 3rd party, or they understand what the other two candidates would have done to Ontario, let alone our Country.

    Now, whinnie the pooh was, IMO a very, very poor choice for a candidate. We have seen what she promises and, quite frankly, has had her time in the spotlight. This is evident as to how Canadians have voted, with the exception of Thunder bay that is. We’ve had many advances in LBGT-Apache helicopter rights, increased minimum wage, and have done things socially (mostly) that have been needed for some time, such as decriminalization of a specific plant. Then there was the bad things, like hydro privatization, and many, many more blunders. People tend to remember the bad things more readily though, and privatizing the hydro sector was, IMO, her kill stroke.

    Lets now look at the NDP…. Sanctuary province…. Want to talk about long wait times? how does absolutely free health care for everyone that steps foot in Ontario sound? I can tell you that it sounds like a day wait time, more “hallway medicine”, and ultimately, the collapse of Ontario, if not Canada.

    So what does that leave us with? Mr. Ford, and 3rd party reps. But everyone is afraid to vote for ACTUAL CHANGE, like the NOP or green parties, so we change between the trio, but complain when nothing really changes. Want something different? Vote green, vote NOP, hell, vote the karl marks party (don’t do that).

    • As an Economist said, the debt can be carried if the Economy is wrong, under Ford and the risk of cuts there will be a recession in the coming years

  3. Ford is on record…on all media types…stating that there will be no loss of jobs for nurses and teachers. This will be interesting to watch. He can always change his mind once he sees the Liberals left a bigger mess than was known.

      • You are delusional if you think that there won’t be cuts or freezes to programming or sector jobs, that is why there wasn’t a PLATFORM PLAN Ontario Voters have once again voted in a Leader with NO EXPERIENCE AT All and we will pay and by the way healthcare has been free for all it is called OHIP

  4. Consider the debt how does anyone think you can improve everything and get out of debt
    People are so naive Complain about the debt but how do you improve anything esp after liberals have been in power Sure everything needs improved but it is not going to happen on that scale overnite

    • Anne you are worried about a debt according the economist that a healthy economy can carry a debt which the risk of cuts it will lead to a RECESSION which is far worst

      • sure go ahead and cut the CEOs salary and pay them peanuts, just see how well things are run by someone with only the education, experience and qualification to run the place while making less then any of the doctors. These guys are not like the clowns running Hydro one making millions.

    • Why not ask Ford to cut his salary as Premier, he is a Millionaire, an elite this way it will go back to the budget food for thought

  5. Speculations? Great news reporting. Wouldn’t expect anything better. Where were you when the liberals cut beds and closed down wings? How long of a wait time do you think you’d have if Americans came across for free health care and dental under the NDP? Look for any truth. Not this garbage

  6. If the provincial conservatives are anything like the ones in Manitoba it means hiring a business consultant to see where cuts can be made and closing 3/4 of the hospitals and ERs. Then they add chairs around the nursing desk and mark those patients as seen while they sit there for 48 hours so they can tell the public that wait time has improved.

LEAVE A REPLY