New Tory motion could trigger second confidence showdown for Liberal minority

Erin O'Toole

OTTAWA — One day after surviving a confidence vote on a Conservative motion, Justin Trudeau’s minority Liberal government faces another Conservative motion that could trigger yet more high-stakes drama over the possibility of a snap election in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic.

The official Opposition is using its second opposition day this week to debate a motion calling for a sweeping probe by the House of Commons health committee into a host of issues relating to the government’s handling of the COVID-19 pandemic.

The motion is so broad and the demand for documents so massive that the Liberals are expected to argue that its passage would paralyze the government — the same argument used to declare the first Conservative motion a confidence matter.

The government survived the subsequent confidence vote on that motion — which would have created a special committee to investigate the WE Charity affair and other alleged examples of corruption — with NDP, Green and independent MPs grudgingly joining with the Liberals on Wednesday to defeat the motion.

But all opposition parties blamed Prime Minister Trudeau for turning the issue into a confidence matter that threatened to plunge the country into an election.

With opposition resentment over the handling of that motion still fresh, the government now has to decide whether to play the same card again on the second Conservative motion.

Today’s motion was actually introduced by Conservative MP Michelle Rempel Garner at the health committee several weeks ago, where it appeared to have the support of Bloc Quebecois and NDP members. But Liberal members argued strenuously at that time that they needed more time to digest such a massive motion.

Using an argument that’s likely to be repeated by government members today, Liberal MP Darren Fisher told the committee that “the motion asks public health officials basically to stop what they’re doing to protect Canadians and sift through emails and documents instead.”

While the motion will be debated in the House of Commons today, it will not be put to a vote until Monday.

Among other things, today’s motion would direct the health committee to scrutinize the government’s slow progress in approving rapid COVID-19 testing, the impact of the government’s reliance on World Health Organization recommendations that delayed travel restrictions and wearing of face masks, the Public Health Agency of Canada’s communications strategy, the partial shutdown of the Global Public Health Intelligence Network early warning system and the adequacy of federal health transfer payments to the provinces.

And it would order the government to turn over all memorandums, emails, documents, notes or other records from the Prime Minister’s Office, the Privy Council Office, various ministers’ offices and departments, and the Public Health Agency of Canada related to:

— Plans and preparations for the pandemic;

—  Communications with the World Health Organization concerning preparations for the pandemic;

—  Purchasing of personal protective equipment;

—  Purchasing of testing products including tests, reagents, swabs, laboratory equipment and other material related to tests used in the diagnosis of COVID-19.

It would also order the government to release all records related to the COVID-19 Vaccine Task Force and its subcommittees and its plans for distributing an eventual vaccine.

The demand for documents concerning the purchase of personal protective equipment could be particularly sensitive for the government. It has used a national security exemption to keep some procurement contracts secret, arguing that the intense global competition for PPE makes it prudent to protect the names of suppliers of items that are particularly hard to come by, such as N95 respirators, gloves and swabs.

A national security exemption also allows the government to purchase supplies more quickly.

The Conservative motion makes some allowance for national security concerns, stipulating that any redactions to the demanded documents be made only by the parliamentary law clerk and only for national security or personal privacy reasons.


  1. What in H### is wrong with the conservative opposition??? We have far bigger problems at the moment than trying to bring down the Liberals.. I realize that they want to be the governing party but right now is not the time to try it.. With a vote of No-Confidence virtually all government support during this Covid crisis would come to a halt and win, lose or draw, we the people would be the biggest losers.. I have voted Conservative in the past but never will again.. This goes beyond stupidity……

    • Wow Bill, are you ever missing the point. Liberal corruption has actually made the covid crisis worse.
      Among other covid failures, Trudeau’s government:
      Telling Canadians that there was no person-to-person spread of COVID-19;
      Telling Canadians that border control measures and masks didn’t work;
      Sending critical supplies of personal protective equipment (PPE) to China when [Canada] had a shortage;
      Receiving from China tons of contaminated and defective PPE in return;
      Abdicating responsibility for the pandemic to the provinces;
      Failing to ensure Canadians have access to rapid and at-home testing options;
      Shutting down the federal pandemic early warning system, just months before COVID-19
      Telling Canadians borders were closed yet still allowing daily flights;
      Continuing to allow “irregular” border crossings”
      Continuing to push immigration during a pandemic with only voluntary honour system self isolation
      Canada is WORSE off directly because of Trudeau, and we haven’t even touched on the non-covid scandals.

      • Were all still doing quite well, far better than most other countries, just look at our PERFECT neighbors next door…Do you actually think we would have been better off with Andy Sneer running the country??? To each their own poison but the Cons need to start trying to help the country at the moment. Last thing we need is an election at this time..And by the way, some of your info is a bit skewed too. Don’t believe everything your party tells you..

        • Wrong on so many counts.
          Many of the rates in the U.S. have been controversial, and in many cases rates have been exaggerated or prone to skewed reported rates. Which country recently lost approval for travel into the European union? Canada.
          Which country is now being criticized internationally for poor handling and low testing of covid? Canada
          “Andy Sneer running the country??? To each their own poison but the Cons need… ” You’ve exposed your agenda right there. People like you are the problem who are blinded by emotion. Justin Trudeau has domestically and internationally been recognized at mishandling covid – there are still a few Canadians who have fallen for his spin doctoring of perception. You don’t have to like the conservatives, but WAKE UP! Trudeau has badly mismanaged Canada and put us on a downward spiral that’ll take Canadians decades, if we can ever, recover from. And I guess we can thank Trudeau supporters like you.
          Worst Prime Minister in Canadian history.

Comments are closed.