Millroy: Council Needs a Mask By-Law


Residents of the Sault have done well in following Algoma Public Health’s policy directing that businesses/organizations adopt a policy that requires all members of the public and employees who enter or remain in an enclosed public space to wear a mask or face covering.

I think that has gone a long way toward keeping the infection rate low in the Sault area with, as of this writing, only 58 positive cases being reported out of 59,796 tests and only one remaining active.

But over the past few weeks I have noted some loosening up within both the public and businesses.

I note more among the public not wearing masks, some flat out saying that no one is going to force them to do so either. And even with some who are wearing them, it is not being done correctly. Some are wearing them below the nose and in more extreme cases, below even the mouth.

In regard to businesses, some employees working behind protective Plexiglass shields can be seen not wearing masks.

As it is only a policy as APH does not have the power to mandate the wearing of masks, there is no penalty for business owners who do not require both employees and customers to wear masks, nor is there any penalty for the employees or the customers.

Only a bylaw passed by city council will do that, since the provincial government is on record as saying that mandating the wearing of masks is a step it doesn’t want to take, believing, it seems, that it won’t go over well politically with the electorate.

Our council received an update on the Corona-19 virus and APH’s policy from Dr. Jennifer Loo, then associate medical officer of health, this past summer.

At the time some councillors brought up the subject of a bylaw that would have given some teeth to the APH policy but they didn’t press it, the result seeming to be that they could quickly come up with a bylaw if and when we got hit hard with the virus.

I would have preferred council to have chosen to be proactive rather than reactive in this situation.

After all, the virus seems to be rearing its ugly head in greater numbers across the country.
In Ontario, the provincial government ordered lockdowns in the hotspots of Toronto and Peel Region starting this week, although schools and child care centres will remain open.

The move will close cinemas, gyms, museums and sports facilities, and will restrict restaurants to all but delivery and takeout. Retail stores are also set to be limited to curbside pickup and delivery only.

This is somewhat different than some of the moves made in the United States, where places like New York have closed down schools but allowed the rest to remain open.

Considering the positivity rate in schools is much lower than in the other places named, there seems to be some logic missing from the decision-making process.

My worry is that when the virus strikes, it can multiply in clusters very fast.

That is why I would like to have seen council mandate the wearing of masks

The APH policy got most of us wearing them. A bylaw with the force of law and its attendant penalties behind it would go a long way toward bringing the rest along.

Those who don’t will get hit pretty hard in the pocketbook.

The city doesn’t have to go far to look for examples of cities with bylaws.

London city council this past summer passed a temporary by-law, on the advice of the Chief Medical Officer of Health, which requires residents to wear a mask or face covering in all enclosed publicly-accessible spaces in London.

Upon conviction of an offence under this by-law, a person or operator shall be liable to a fine in accordance with section 429 of the Municipal Act, 2001, as follows:
A minimum of $500 and a maximum fine of $100,000. In the case of a continuing offence, for each day or part of a day that the offence continues, a minimum of $500 and a maximum fine of $10,000, and the total of all daily fines for the offence is not limited to $100,000..

As I said in an earlier column, those are pretty hefty fines and would certainly catch the attention of the public and business owners.

All it would have taken for the Sault to have a bylaw would have been for Loo to ask council for one.

Instead, the health unit simply went on its own, putting forth a policy that it hoped businesses, organizations and the public would follow.

These bylaws will not be in force forever, but I believe they are required at this time to keep Covid-19 at bay.

I realize that if the request for a bylaw comes to council it could move quickly to bring it about.

But I would still prefer that it was already on the books.


  1. Hey CW, that’s what the plexiglass glass is for!!!! Thanks Dave! Oh and by the way, look on your box of masks, it will clearly state does not protect against viruses, just saying!!!!!

  2. You mentioned people are wearing them incorrectly, what about the men wearing them with full beards the mask is no where near being a tight fit to the face. Is that ok Doug

  3. The Soo is doing very well in the mask wearing department. I very seldom see people not complying but, we do have to be mindful of those who are medically exempt. Glad our cases have gone down again.

    • WIth 1 road into town, 1 road out, no passenger rail, low population density and “closed” international borders there’s no excuse to be pretty well at zero cases. Should be a slam dunk,

  4. I am not sure where you shop Doug but everywhere I go everyone is wearing a mask. I am quite impressed with the cooperation Sault residents are showing in this regard. Keep in mind if you make a law…someone has to enforce it. Who might that be?

    • At the grocery store I usually count 2-4 people per store not wearing a mask and see many more standing close to each other and chatting outside stores. I do see many more people taking off their mask to talk on the phone or having their mask pulled down below their nose.
      On my street there are a couple houses with get-togethers every weekend and judging by the groups outside smoking & drinking it’s a safe assumption they aren’t wearing masks.
      I went to a local store on Sunday – my glasses were fogging up and the employee said to “just take off your mask we don’t care if people wear them”.
      Not really anything to be impressed with.

        • No exaggeration there. I’ve noticed the same thing.
          School boards have been receiving many complaints due to high school students congregating in large numbers in close proximity without masks, entering nearby stores without masks. So many ostriches with their heads buries in the sand.

Comments are closed.