OP-ED: Mercury poisoning from eating fish in Algoma

12

by Peter Chow

Ontario has joined Michigan’s health department with a warning against eating smelts from Lake Superior.

Sault-based tournament angler and Algoma Fish and Game Club member Jason Doyon was diagnosed with mercury poisoning from eating fish last year.

Doyon was experiencing a multitude of symptoms affecting both his physical and mental state.

“Extreme muscle weakness, muscle fatigue. I was walking around like I was drunk all the time, my gait was off. I was stumbling a lot all over the place. I was moody all the time, I couldn’t focus. Lethargic, tired, cold,” he said.

Doyon was diagnosed with mercury poisoning last year after undergoing almost every sort of test imaginable beginning in December 2019. Prior to the diagnosis, the tournament angler would eat fish up to four times a week.

The Sault-based tournament angler has been researching Ontario’s guidelines for fish consumption ever since.

Doyon has undergone 15 rounds of chelation therapy to remove the toxic mercury from his body, since May 2020.

Toxins in fish are subject “food pyramids,” in which toxins bioaccumulate in higher and higher concentrations, the higher you go in the food pyramid.

Therefore, it follows that large “apex predators” at the top of the food pyramids would have the highest concentrations of toxins.

Man is at the apex.

Therefore, do not eat large fish.

This is not new and goes back to the discovery of Minimata disease.

Minamata disease, is a neurological disease caused by mercury poisoning.  Signs and symptoms include ataxia, numbness in the hands and feet, general muscle weakness, loss of peripheral vision, and damage to hearing and speech.  In extreme cases, insanity, paralysis, coma, and death follow within weeks of the onset of symptoms.  A congenital form of the disease can also affect fetuses in the womb.

Minamata disease, discovered in the city of Minamata, Japan, in 1956, was caused by the release of mercury in the industrial wastewater from a chemical factory.

This highly toxic heavy metal bioaccumulated and biomagnified in shellfish and fish, which, when eaten by the local population, resulted in mercury poisoning.

As of March 2001, 2,265 victims had been officially recognised as having Minamata disease (1,784 of whom had died).

rassy Narrows First Nation is an Ojibwe First Nations band in  northern Kenora that fell victim to mercury poisoning from the Dryden Chemical Company and the Dryden Pulp and Paper Company.  10 tons (20,000 pounds) of mercury was dumped into the Wabigoon River system between 1962 and 1970.

Despite the fact that walleye in the area contain approximately 13-15 times the recommended levels of mercury, the First Nation group still consumes the mercury-infested fish, due to cultural tradition and socioeconomic factors.

Places near industries have long harboured contaminated fish.

What is new and alarming in the recent reports is the contamination of smelts. They are close to the bottom of food pyramids and all predators eat them given the opportunity.

In the case of smelts in Michigan, the toxins are the “forever chemicals,” PFOS and PFAS, not mercury.

It is very disturbing that this much PFOS & PFAS is in Lake  Superior.

Jason Doyon was mercury-poisoned, almost with certainty, by consuming many larger fish. Large walleye, in particular, can be heavily contaminated by mercury.

Our MNR should be loud and clear about this matter.

Accurate consumption guides are urgent and should be much more readily available than through internet research.

According to Ontario’s guidelines the province recommends that absolutely no smelts from Lake Superior, from the upper portion of the St. Mary’s River all the way up to Batchewana Bay, should be consumed by the public.

The public should study the province’s online guide to eating fish before consuming ANY fish from Lake Superior, the North Channel and inland lakes.

The issue extends to the commercial fishing industry.

Doyon points out that the areas on the province’s interactive map  run from the Soo Locks all the way to Georgian Bay east of Manitoulin Island, advising zero consumption for any whitefish over 22 inches.

Commercial fishing nets generally catch only larger whitefish.

Which means that the public could be ingesting fish from a restaurant or grocery store with high levels of mercury contamination without even realizing it.

The following is a list of water bodies in the Algoma District compiled by Doyon that currently have zero consumption advisories, according to provincial data:

  • St. Marys River ~ Zero Atlantic Salmon over 24”, Chinook Salmon over 18”, Smallmouth Bass over 14”
  • McCarroll Lake ~ Zero Lake Trout over 20”
  • Tunnel Lake ~ Zero northern pike over 30 inches, zero walleye over 24 inches
  • Rock Lake ~ Zero Northern Pike over 30”, Smallmouth Bass over 18”, Walleye over 18”
  • Echo Lake ~ Walleye over 26”, Northern Pike over 28”
  • Montreal River Reservoir ~ Zero northern pike over 26 inches, zero walleye over 22 inches
  • Lake Superior, Goulais Bay area ~ Zero rainbow smelt of any size
  • Lake Superior, Agawa Bay and north ~ Zero lake trout over 24 inches, zero walleye over 30 inches
  • Lake Huron, North Channel ~ Zero Chinook Salmon over 16”, Lake Trout over 20”, Lake Whitefish over 18”, Pink Salmon over 20”, Rainbow Trout over 20”, Smallmouth Bass over 14”, Walleye over 30”

An extended list of consumption guidelines for the Algoma District complied by Doyon can be found on the Algoma Fish and Game Club Facebook page as well as an online Interactive Guide to Eating Ontario Fish available from the province.

The major source of mercury in Lake Superior is from gold mining. Red Pine Exploration has discovered a new gold zone at its Wawa Gold Project, two kilometres southeast of town. The Island Gold Mine, 15 kilometres east of Dubreuilville, 83 kilometres northeast of Wawa, has ramped back up. The Eagle River Complex, located 50 kilometres due west of Wawa, consists of two operating gold mines, the Eagle River Underground Mine and the Mishi Open Pit Mine.

Gold mining has ravaged landscapes, contaminated water supplies, and contributed to the destruction of vital ecosystems.

Most gold is “Dirty Gold”, really, really dirty. There is no such thing as clean gold, unless it’s recycled or vintage. Modern industrial gold mining destroys ecosystems and creates huge amounts of toxic waste.

Due to the use of dirty practices such as open pit mining and cyanide heap leaching, mining companies generate about 20 tons of toxic waste for every 0.333-ounce gold ring. The waste, usually a gray liquid sludge, is laden with deadly cyanide and toxic heavy metals, mercury, lead and cadmium.

The use of mercury in gold mining is causing a global health and environmental crisis.

For every gram of gold produced, gold miners release about two grams of mercury into the environment;  1,000 tons of mercury into the environment each year, or 35% of global man-made mercury pollution.

When mercury reaches rivers, lakes, and oceans, it can travel across great distances. Once it reaches a resting place, mercury is not easily removed.

Sediments on the floor of San Francisco Bay remain contaminated with mercury left by the California gold rush of the 19th century.

Mercury is a heavy metal, extremely harmful to human health, proven to damage the kidneys, liver, brain, heart, lungs, colon, and immune system.

Mercury causes neurological damage, the effects most pronounced in children who are still developing, the damage including cognitive damage and low IQ, slow reflexes, impaired coordination, damaged motor skills, problems with memory and concentration and symptoms of ADHD.

Companies mining for gold and other metals dump at least 200 million tons of toxic waste into rivers, lakes, and oceans each year—more than 1.5 times the waste that U.S. cities send to landfills on a yearly basis.

To limit the environmental damage, mines often construct dams and keep the toxic waste inside. But these dams do not prevent contamination of the surrounding environment. Toxic waste easily seeps into soil and groundwater, or is released in catastrophic spills.

The majority of the world’s gold is extracted from open pit mines, where huge volumes of earth are scoured away and processed for trace elements. To produce enough raw gold to make a single ring, 20 tons of rock and soil are dislodged and discarded. Much of this waste carries with it mercury and cyanide, which are used to extract the gold from the rock.

The resulting erosion clogs streams and rivers and the mercury and cyanide eventually ends up in marine ecosystems far downstream of the mine site.

In the case of Wawa, this means Lake Superior and the Great Lakes.

Short-term profit for long-term loss – something for everyone in the Great Lakes basin, not just Wawa, to ponder.

12 COMMENTS

  1. Maybe the doctor just doesn’t have time to reply to your ignorant posts. Look how bad the environment is getting. Very sad when you even have to watch what you eat out of inland lakes. The Indians are the only ones that make a stand and they get all kinds of criticism. The poor world we live in is going for a giant dump.

  2. Key sources of mercury emissions in North America differ depending on the region.

    In Canada, the main source of mercury releases to the environment are from the mining and smelting industry, whereas coal-fired electricity generation facilities are the
    predominant emission sources in the United States.

    Canadian mines produced an estimated 175 tonnes of gold in 2019, which is a 70% increase over gold production in 2010.

    Ontario is Canada’s largest producer of gold, with more than 42%% of all the gold mined in Canada.

    The risk associated with mercury toxicity can create undue hardships, not only to the individuals and families who suffer the effects of mercury contamination, but also to the economy at large, through increased education and health costs, and reduced productivity.

    Mercury exposure in pre-natal or young children is associated with learning disabilities, which are on the increase

    Mercury of course is one of only a host of risk factors for these and other disorders.

    However it is important to understand the magnitude of the impacts which are being felt in society to which mercury exposure is a contributor.

    For Great Lakes fish with mercury levels in excess of health guidelines, the historical policy response from governments has been the issuance of fish advisories that inform anglers of which fish are safe to eat.

    While important, there are many limitations to this system that can lead to frequent human exposure to mercury above health guidelines.

    Research has shown that many anglers either ignore fish advisories or are unaware of them.

    A Health Canada study found that only one-third of the people eating fish from heavily contaminated waters in Ontario use the province’s sport fish consumption guide.

    The Federal Environmental Commissioner criticized Health Canada for failing to properly communicate the risks to fish consumers.

    The commercial sale of Great Lakes fish with elevated levels of mercury is also a concern.

    Consumers purchasing fish from markets or restaurants are even less likely to be aware of fish advisories, and, unlike anglers, often don’t know enough about fish terminology to interpret fish advisories properly.

    Independent testing on fish caught from Lake Huron showed that fillets approached or even exceeded Health Canada guidelines for mercury.

    Despite this, fish from the lake sold in commercial markets had not undergone testing for chemical contaminants since at least 1996.

    The Canadian Food Inspection Agency admitted that commercial fishing licenses in Lake Huron are being granted based on science that needs updating.

    According to the Great Lakes Science Advisory Board, recent research on methylmercury in fish and human health suggests that current advisories are outdated, and may not be protecting
    public health.

    37% of Ontario’s population participates in sports fishing an average of 5 times per year.

    Given the health impacts of even low levels of mercury exposure, the importance of up-to-date and well-communicated advisories cannot be understated.

    The long-term goal however must be the reduction of mercury levels in fish in the Great Lakes.

    http://www3.cec.org/islandora/en/item/2098-mercury-in-great-lakes-basin-final-report-en.pdf

  3. Quentin Yarle:

    Michigan Tech News – The Legacy of Mercury in Lake Superior

    https://www.mtu.edu/news/stories/2016/march/legacy-mercury-lake-superior.html

    “We document that the mining effort was discharging mercury at 1,000 times the normal deposition rate in the region,” says W. Charles Kerfoot, a professor of biology and director of the Lake Superior Ecosystem Research Center at Michigan Tech. “We set out to quantify this deposition—and it was a real wake-up call.”

    “But here, we can show that the amount of mercury in the environment due to local activities is huge compared to the amount coming from other sources like regional coal power plants.”

  4. Quentin Yarle

    Advanced mercury removal from gold leachate solutions prior to gold and silver extraction: a field study from an active gold mine in Peru
    https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11999077/

    “Mercury contamination in the Gold-Cyanide Process (GCP) is a serious health and environmental problem. Following the heap leaching of gold and silver ores with NaCN solutions, portions of the mercury-cyano complexes often adhere to the activated carbon (AC) used to extract the gold. During the electrowinning and retorting steps, mercury can be (and often is) emitted to the air as a vapor. This poses a severe health hazard to plant workers and the local environment. Additional concerns relate to the safety of workers when handling the mercury-laden AC. Currently, mercury treatment from the heap leach solution is nonexistent. This is due to the fact that chelating ligands which can effectively work under the adverse pH conditions (as present in the heap leachate solutions) do not exist.”

  5. I caught a 12 pound walleye in the St. Mary’s last fall in front of the Soo Warehouse. It had a horrible looking growth on the side of it’s head the size of a hardball.
    I did not return it to the water but disposed of it in a proper manner. I’ll never eat fish from the St. Mary’s river ever again.

  6. I know of no regulated mining companies that use mercury. In the 1800s – yes. No longer. The U.S. Geological Survey confirms that most of the mercury in Lake Superior is coming from airborne deposition, mercury that floated around in the atmosphere before falling into the lake in rain and snow.

    Mercury is an issue – no doubt – however to imply that it is being used in todays approaches to logging and mining is ingenious. More mercury hits the atmosphere from coal burning power plants.

    Mercury is a heavy metal. It is an inert metal. Mercury as an inorganic metal is not as toxic as its organic form, methyl mercury, which is formed by bacteria. The organic form is bioavailable—meaning it is readily taken up and stored in organisms—and tends to accumulate up the food chain.

    Dr. Chow you should really look into heap leaching – again a practice NOW heavily regulated in Canada (as it should be) as a means of extraction. Recovery of the chemical used in leaching are recovered as they are expensive! Heap leaching can take anywhere from a couple of months to several years, compared to the 24 hours required by a conventional CIP or CIL process.

    Generating fear is one method of imposing your view on matters. it is not the recommended approach. I think we have had enough fear this year. Education, mitigation and a rational approach to exploitation of natural resources is needed. Mistakes of the past either born of ignorance or willful neglect must not be repeated.

    • Funny how the doctor was quick to respond to someone who agreed with his view but when challenged by you and quite intelligently may i add we see nothing. Refreshing to see an educated approach when dealing with issues of the environment instead of an approach based on fear and personal opinion.

  7. The Lake Superior shoreline along Sault Ste Maroe has been categorized as an international area of concern due to high levels of toxicity for well over 20 years.
    On top of that several years ago Algoma U did a study and found a large percentage of fish they sampled have many benign and cancerous tumours.
    Our waterfront is very toxic.

  8. Does this also mean the water is contaminated as many of us get our drinking water from lake superior hmm

  9. I find many of Dr. Chow’s articles to come off more of a “look at me, I’m the expert of everything” tone. I found more information from a quick google search.

Comments are closed.